@article {tu2015GJIsem,
	title = {Source estimation with surface-related multiples{\textendash}-fast ambiguity-resolved seismic imaging},
	journal = {Geophysical Journal International},
	volume = {205},
	year = {2016},
	note = {(published online in Geophysical Journal International)},
	month = {03},
	pages = {1492-1511},
	abstract = {We address the problem of obtaining a reliable seismic image without prior knowledge of the source wavelet, especially from data that contain strong surface-related multiples. Conventional reverse-time migration requires prior knowledge of the source wavelet, which is either technically or computationally challenging to accurately determine; inaccurate estimates of the source wavelet can result in seriously degraded reverse-time migrated images, and therefore wrong geological interpretations. To solve this problem, we present a "wavelet-free" imaging procedure that simultaneously inverts for the source wavelet and the seismic image, by tightly integrating source estimation into a fast least-squares imaging framework, namely compressive imaging, given a reasonably accurate background velocity model. However, this joint inversion problem is difficult to solve as it is plagued with local minima and the ambiguity with respect to amplitude scalings because of the multiplicative, and therefore nonlinear, appearance of the source wavelet in the otherwise linear formalism. We have found a way to solve this nonlinear joint-inversion problem using a technique called variable projection, and a way to overcome the scaling ambiguity by including surface-related multiples in our imaging procedure following recent developments in surface-related multiple prediction by sparse inversion. As a result, we obtain without prior knowledge of the source wavelet high-resolution seismic images, comparable in quality to images obtained assuming the true source wavelet is known. By leveraging the computationally efficient compressive-imaging methodology, these results are obtained at affordable computational costs compared with conventional processing work flows that include surface-related multiple removal and reverse-time migration.},
	keywords = {computational seismology, free surface, Inverse theory, multiples, seismic imaging, time series analysis, wave propagation},
	url = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Journals/GeophysicalJournalInternational/2016/tu2015GJIsem/tu2015GJIsem.pdf},
	url2 = {http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/content/205/3/1492.full.pdf?keytype=ref\&ijkey=zFydRGQpiJzeCS9},
	author = {Ning Tu and Aleksandr Y. Aravkin and Tristan van Leeuwen and Tim T.Y. Lin and Felix J. Herrmann}
}
@mastersthesis {tu2015THfis,
	title = {Fast imaging with surface-related multiples},
	year = {2015},
	note = {(PhD)},
	month = {08},
	school = {The University of British Columbia},
	type = {phd},
	address = {Vancouver},
	abstract = {Surface-related multiples, which are waves that bounce more than once between the water surface and the subsurface reflectors, constitute a significant part of the data acquired in marine seismic surveys. If left untreated, they can lead to misplaced phantom reflectors in the image, and result in erroneous interpretations of the subsurface structure. As a result, these multiples are removed before the imaging procedure in conventional seismic data processing. However, because they interact more with the subsurface medium, they may carry extra information that is not present in the primaries. Therefore instead of removing these multiples, a more desirable alternative is to make active use of them. We derive from the well-established "Surface-Related Multiple Elimination" relation, and arrive at a linearized expression of the wave-equation based modelling that incorporates the surface- related multiples. We then present a computationally efficient approach to iteratively invert this expression to obtain an image of the subsurface from data that contain multiples. We achieve the computational efficiency inside each iteration by (i) using the wave-equation solver to implicitly carry out the expensive multiple prediction; and (ii) reducing the number of wave-equation solves during data simulation by subsampling the monochromatic source experiments. We show that, compared with directly applying the cross-correlation/deconvolutional imaging conditions, the presented approach can suppress the coherent imaging artifacts from multiples more effectively. We also show that, by curvelet-domain sparsity promoting and occasionally drawing new data samples during the inversion, the proposed inversion method gains improved robustness to velocity errors in the background model, as well as modelling errors incurred during linearization of the wave-equation. To combine the information encoded in both the primaries and the multiples, we then propose a highly accurate source estimation method to jointly invert the total upgoing wavefield. We show with field data examples that we can reap benefits from both the relative noise-free primaries and the extra illumination coverage of the multiples. We also demonstrate that the inclusion of multiples help mitigate the amplitude ambiguity during source estimation. We conclude the thesis with an outlook for future research directions, as well as potential extensions of the proposed work.},
	keywords = {inversion, least-squares, multiples, seismic imaging},
	url = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Thesis/2015/tu2015THfis/tu2015THfis.pdf},
	presentation = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Thesis/2015/tu2015THfis/tu2015THfis_pres.pdf},
	author = {Ning Tu}
}
@article {tu2014fis,
	title = {Fast imaging with surface-related multiples by sparse inversion},
	journal = {Geophysical Journal International},
	volume = {201},
	number = {1},
	year = {2015},
	note = {(Geophysical Journal International)},
	month = {04},
	pages = {304-317},
	abstract = {In marine exploration seismology, surface-related multiples are usually treated as noise mainly because subsequent processing steps, such as migration velocity analysis and imaging, require multiple-free data. Failure to remove these wavefield components from the data may lead to erroneous estimates for migration velocity or result in strong coherent artefacts that interfere with the imaged reflectors. However, multiples can carry complementary information compared to primaries, as they interact with the free surface and are therefore exposed more to the subsurface. Recent work has shown that when processed correctly multiples can improve seismic illumination. Given a sufficiently accurate background velocity model and an estimate for the source signature, we propose a new and computationally efficient linearized inversion procedure based on two-way wave equations, which produces accurate images of the subsurface from the total upgoing wavefield including surface-related multiples. Modelling of the surface-related multiples in the proposed method derives from the well-known surface-related multiple elimination method. We incur a minimal overhead from incorporating the multiples by having the wave-equation solver carry out the multiple predictions via the inclusion of an areal source instead of expensive dense matrix-matrix multiplications. By using subsampling techniques, we obtain high-quality true-amplitude least-squares migrated images at computational costs of roughly a single reverse-time migration (RTM) with all the data. These images are virtually free of coherent artefacts from multiples. Proper inversion of the multiples would be computationally infeasible without using these techniques that significantly bring down the cost. By promoting sparsity in the curvelet domain and using rerandomization, out method gains improved robustness to errors in the background velocity model, and errors incurred in the linearization of the wave equation with respect to the model. We demonstrate the superior performance of the proposed method compared to the conventional RTM using realistic synthetic examples.},
	keywords = {approximate message passing, Compressive Sensing, curvelet, inversion, Kaczmarz, multiples},
	url = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Journals/GeophysicalJournalInternational/2014/tu2014fis/tu2014fis.pdf},
	url2 = {http://gji.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/full/ggv020?ijkey=pKzrSXbtxjlOjzd\&keytype=ref},
	author = {Ning Tu and Felix J. Herrmann}
}
@article {tu2015TLEfls,
	title = {Fast least-squares imaging with surface-related multiples: application to a North-Sea data set},
	journal = {The Leading Edge},
	volume = {34},
	number = {7},
	year = {2015},
	note = {(The Leading Edge)},
	month = {07},
	pages = {788{\textendash}794},
	abstract = {In marine seismic acquisition, surface-related multiples constitute a significant portion of the acquired data. Typically, multiples are removed during early-stage data-processing as they can lead to phantom reflectors during migration that may result in erroneous geological interpretations. However, if properly dealt with, multiples can provide valuable extra information and complement primaries in illuminating the subsurface. In this article, we demonstrate the limitation of the reverse-time migration in imaging these multiples, and present an alternative inversion procedure that is computationally efficient, that jointly maps both primaries and multiples to the true reflectors, and where the source function is estimated on the fly. As a result, we obtain high-quality, mostly artifact-free, broad-band images where the imprint of the source-function are partly removed at a computationally affordable expense compared to the combined costs of the wave-equation based surface-related multiple elimination and the reverse-time migration. We achieve all this by including the total downgoing wavefields as areal sources in the least-squares migration in combination with curvelet-domain sparsity promotion. We apply the proposed method to a shallow-water marine data set from the North sea, which contains abundant short-period surface-related multiples, and show its efficacy in eliminating coherent imaging artifacts associated with these multiples. We also demonstrate the benefits of joint imaging of primaries and multiples compared to imaging these signal components separately.},
	keywords = {field data, inversion, least squares, migration, multiples},
	doi = {10.1190/tle34070788.1},
	url = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Journals/TheLeadingEdge/2015/tu2015TLEfls/tu2015TLEfls.html},
	author = {Ning Tu and Felix J. Herrmann}
}
@conference {tu2015PIMSsls,
	title = {Sparse least-squares seismic imaging with source estimation utilizing multiples},
	booktitle = {PIMS Workshop on Advances in Seismic Imaging and Inversion},
	year = {2015},
	note = {(PIMS Workshop on Advances in Seismic Imaging and Inversion, University of Alberta, Edmonton)},
	month = {05},
	abstract = {We present an least-squares seismic imaging method that (1) is efficient by subsampling the monochromatic source experiments; (2) does not require the prior knowledge of the source wavelet, by inverting for the seismic image and the source wavelet simultaneously using variable projection; and (3) makes active use of surface-related multiples to increase the illumination and to resolve the scaling ambiguity in source estimation, by tightly integrating the well-established surface-related-multiple-prediction into the wave-equation based modelling. As a result, we are able to obtain ambiguity-resolved, high-fidelity least-squares inverted seismic images with computational costs that are comparable to conventional reverse-time migrations with all the data. We demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed method using synthetic examples.},
	keywords = {inversion, least-squares migration, multiples, PIMS, seismic imaging, source estimation, workshop},
	presentation = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Conferences/PIMS/2015/tu2015PIMSsls/tu2015PIMSsls_pres.pdf},
	author = {Ning Tu and Felix J. Herrmann}
}
@conference {herrmann2014SEGWSfli,
	title = {Fast linearized inversion with surface-related multiples with source estimation},
	booktitle = {SEG Workshop on Using Multiples as Signal for Imaging; Denver},
	year = {2014},
	note = {(SEG Workshop, Denver)},
	month = {10},
	abstract = {In the well-known SRME relation, multiples are expressed as the multi-dimensional convolution between the subsurface Green{\textquoteright}s function and the downgoing receiver wavefield. Therefore these multiples can be considered as the response of the subsurface to an "areal" source term given by the same downgoing receiver wavefield. This relation can be used to treat these multiples as signals instead of considering them as noise that must removed before seismic imaging. However, when we use conventional reverse-time migration to image these multiple events, it results in acausal imaging artifacts caused by cross-correlations between wrong pairs of up- and downgoing wavefields. We find that these artifacts can be removed by adopting a sparsity-promoting least-squares inversion approach. However, iterative inversions go at the expense of excessive computational costs. By combining the SRME relation and wave-equation based linearized modelling, we are able to significantly reduce the costs by avoiding the dense matrix-matrix multiplications of SRME and the number of wave-equation solves via source subsampling. As a result, we arrive at a method with a cost comparable to that of a single reverse-time migration with all shots.},
	keywords = {inversion, multiples, SEG, workshop},
	url = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Conferences/SEG/2014/herrmann2014SEGWSfli/herrmann2014SEGWSfli.pdf},
	presentation = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Conferences/SEG/2014/herrmann2014SEGWSfli/herrmann2014SEGWSfli_pres.pdf},
	author = {Ning Tu and Felix J. Herrmann}
}
@conference {tu2013EAGElsm,
	title = {Fast least-squares migration with multiples and source estimation},
	booktitle = {EAGE Annual Conference Proceedings},
	year = {2013},
	month = {06},
	abstract = {The advent of modern computing has made it possible to do seismic imaging using least-squares reverse-time migration. We obtain superior images by solving an optimization problem that recovers the true-amplitude images. However, its success hinges on overcoming several issues, including overwhelming problem size, unknown source wavelet, and interfering coherent events like multiples. In this abstract, we reduce the problem size by using ideas from compressive sensing, and estimate source wavelet by generalized variable projection. We also demonstrate how to invert for subsurface information encoded in surface-related multiples by incorporating the free-surface operator as an areal source in reverse-time migration. Our synthetic examples show that multiples help to improve the resolution of the image, as well as remove the amplitude ambiguity in wavelet estimation.},
	keywords = {EAGE, Imaging, multiples, source estimation, sparse},
	doi = {10.3997/2214-4609.20130727},
	url = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Conferences/EAGE/2013/tu2013EAGElsm/tu2013EAGElsm.pdf},
	presentation = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Conferences/EAGE/2013/tu2013EAGElsm/tu2013EAGElsm_pres.pdf},
	author = {Ning Tu and Aleksandr Y. Aravkin and Tristan van Leeuwen and Felix J. Herrmann}
}
@conference {herrmann2013EAGEfrtm,
	title = {Fast RTM with multiples and source estimation},
	booktitle = {EAGE/SEG Forum - Turning noise into geological information: The next big step?},
	year = {2013},
	month = {11},
	abstract = {During this talk, we present a computationally efficient (cost of 1-2 RTM{\textquoteright}s with all data) iterative sparsity-promoting inversion framework where surface-related multiples are jointly imaged with primaries and where the source signature is estimated on the fly. Our imaging algorithm is computationally efficient because it works during each iteration with small independent randomized subsets of data. The multiples are handled by introducing an areal source term that includes the upgoing wavefield. We update the source signature for each iteration using a variable projection method. The resulting algorithm removes imaging artifacts from surface-related multiples, estimates and removes the imprint of the source, recovers true amplitudes, is fast, and robust to linearization errors by virtue of the statistical independence of the subsets of data we are working with at each iteration.},
	keywords = {EAGE, multiples, RTM, SEG, source estimation},
	url = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Conferences/EAGE/2013/herrmann2013EAGEfrtm/herrmann2013EAGEfrtm_pres.pdf},
	author = {Felix J. Herrmann and Ning Tu}
}
@conference {tu2013SEGldi,
	title = {Limitations of the deconvolutional imaging condition for two-way propagators},
	booktitle = {SEG Technical Program Expanded Abstracts},
	volume = {32},
	year = {2013},
	month = {09},
	pages = {3916-3920},
	abstract = {The deconvolutional imaging condition has gained wide attention in recent years, as it is often used to image surface-related multiples. However, we noticed on close inspection that this condition was derived from one-way propagation principles. Now that two-way wave-equation based simulations have become more affordable, we revisit the deconvolutional imaging condition and reveal its limitations for two-way propagators. First, it can distort the image due to receiver-side propagation effects. Second, when used to image surface-related multiples, it is not capable of removing all interfering phantom reflectors.},
	keywords = {inversion, migration, multiples, SEG},
	doi = {10.1190/segam2013-1440.1},
	url = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Conferences/SEG/2013/tu2013SEGldi/tu2013SEGldi.pdf},
	presentation = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Conferences/SEG/2013/tu2013SEGldi/tu2013SEGldi_pres.pdf},
	author = {Ning Tu and Tristan van Leeuwen and Felix J. Herrmann}
}
@conference {tu2012SEGima,
	title = {Imaging with multiples accelerated by message passing},
	booktitle = {SEG Technical Program Expanded Abstracts},
	volume = {31},
	year = {2012},
	month = {11},
	pages = {1-6},
	publisher = {SEG},
	organization = {SEG},
	abstract = {With the growing realization that multiples can provide valuable information, there is a paradigm shift from removing them to using them. For instance, primary estimation by sparse inversion has demonstrated its superiority over surface-related multiple removal in many aspects. Inspired by this shift, we propose a method to image directly from the total up-going wavefield, including surface-related multiples, by sparse inversion. To address the high computational cost associated with this method, we propose to speed up the inversion by having the wave-equation solver carry out the multi-dimensional convolutions implicitly and cheaply by randomized subsampling. We improve the overall performance of this algorithm by selecting new independent copies of the randomized modeling operator, which leads to a cancellation of correlations that hamper the speed of convergence of the solver. We show the merits of our approach on a number of examples.},
	keywords = {Imaging, multiples, SEG},
	doi = {10.1190/segam2012-1552.1},
	url = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Conferences/SEG/2012/tu2012SEGima/tu2012SEGima.pdf},
	presentation = {https://slim.gatech.edu/Publications/Public/Conferences/SEG/2012/tu2012SEGima/tu2012SEGima_pres.pdf},
	author = {Ning Tu and Felix J. Herrmann}
}
